AQSIQ six accused refused to disclose the report Detected Products
AQSIQ did not make public the report, many times, so that users are satisfied with business. Zhejiang Venture thin leaf Ltd. Chairman, said: "We are Zhengzhou Tuopu Health of gas, are now angry with AQSIQ Health."
Referred to as "the biggest patent infringement in 2006 was" the first instance, the prevailing party – Zhengzhou Top Rolling Technology Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to Zhengzhou Tuopu) mill production, but for 3 years in a number of the National People’s Congress submitted to the two proposals being referred to as fake and shoddy products. Is it true or false? By the end of 2007, AQSIQ organized group of experts to form a "Detect expert report" on the Zhengzhou Tuopu mill investigation and identification. But since then, has been AQSIQ 6th National People’s Congress and refuse to open the report related businesses.
In this regard, the proposal submitted on behalf of the National People’s Congress believe that the General Administration of Quality Supervision, Zhengzhou Tuopu shield so that many users suffer huge losses Enterprise a few years without compensation. Zhengzhou Tuopu said that this is the original case against infringement on their defamation and continuing infringement.
Seems complicated and confusing months in automatically. AQSIQ has this report is it? If so, why has not be made public? With these questions, "Daily News" reporter started a thorough investigation.
User enterprises: the use of the tremendous loss of Zhengzhou Tuopu mill
"The proposed commission of inquiry composed of the National People’s Congress to oversee the AQSIQ perform its regulatory functions, based on" expert report Detected "promptly investigate and deal with quality problems in Zhengzhou case Tuopu mill to prevent the ‘Sanlu Incident’ means of production at the field of play." This is The End of the country on the two month period, the Eleventh National People’s Congress Wang’s proposals.
This is No. 3 on behalf of the National People’s Congress in two sessions on the National Tuopu mill against the quality problem.
Wang the recommendations in the word "fake" means by zhengzhou Rolling Technology Co., Ltd. Chairman Tuopu professionals ZHENG Hong, general manager of LIN Zhao and his wife in 1992, developed with independent intellectual property rights XGK mill.
Venture Ltd. Zhejiang sheet Tuopu Zhengzhou on the purchase of this mill. Leaf Chairman of the company told reporters that they purchase in 2003, a price 40 million yuan, together with supporting facilities, a total investment of more than 1 million. After put into production, producing over 1000 tons per month, amounting to less than the basic productivity, quality Tuopu Zhengzhou is not as advertised, a great error, resulting in a loss of the company at least tens of millions of dollars a year. "I start in 2005 in Zhengzhou Tuopu to reflect these circumstances, but they are ignored."
Horse Copper Co., Ltd. Zhejiang Acer Acer Chairman should be marked told reporters that his company has encountered the same situation, a huge loss.
Tenth National People’s Congress, told reporters on behalf of hole current to the domestic enterprises in Zhengzhou Tuopu 8 Units mill sold an average of a rolling mill facilities need to add nearly 2 billion, these enterprises have been a huge loss, production and so on. At him and called for business users, in October 2007 from 25 to 27, General Administration of Quality Supervision metallurgical composition of the national quality supervision and inspection of heavy machinery-based Center 7 team of experts to consider mill Zhengzhou Tuopu quality Nantong, Huaxi investigate two users. In November the same year, the Group of 29 will be "Detected investigate report" to the AQSIQ.
National People’s Congress: 6 meeting AQSIQ refused to disclose the report
The Eleventh National People’s Congress this year at the recommendation of Wang was also wrote: "Start AQSIQ investigation procedures, especially in the" expert report Detected "Tuopu Zhengzhou mill that serious quality problems exist, not only to stop the investigation process, investigated and dealt with the failure to fulfill the duty of fake and shoddy products, and even low-grade mill Tuopu Zhengzhou indulgence and shielding, which trades on the healthy development of China’s cold has resulted in serious interference and damage. "
The Tenth National People’s Congress, told reporters hole, January 7, 2008, he was commissioned by the National People’s Congress 15, the Product Quality Supervision General Administration of Quality Supervision Division to see the expert reports. The Expert Group will be the quality of Zhengzhou mill problem Tuopu all made into a color photo of a serious quality problem in a different font color marked focus. As outlined in the report proved the existence of Zhengzhou Tuopu mill serious quality problem, the National People’s Congress investigate and understand the situation exactly the same.
Kong said at the time, Deputy Director and Director of the High Jianzhong Liu Chunyan, he would insist the report does not allow copying to other NPC deputies, the General Administration of Quality Supervision only read, and stressed that this is the views of AQSIQ.
Subsequently, the two-hole sent a letter to General Administration of Quality Supervision, General Administration of hope to the National People’s Congress on behalf of other public reports, and deal with the views of Zhengzhou Tuopu out. But since then, AQSIQ has refused to disclose the report.
From the beginning in September 2008, Zhengzhou Tuopu mill users, metallurgical industry experts and lawyers on behalf of part of the National People’s Congress Wang started the "Government information open regulations", the joint submission to the General Administration of Quality Supervision, "Government information open the application", requiring expert’s report to the public.
Kong said they have so far submitted 7 applications, the General Administration of Quality Supervision reply 6 times in the last reply on March 18 this year, but the Administration has yet to report on the expert conclusion of the specific content or give a reply.
AQSIQ: no report, no conclusions
Why AQSIQ experts throughout the non-disclosure of the report?
A few days ago, the State General Administration of Quality Supervision Division Director of Product Quality Supervision and high on the "Daily Economic News" reporter, said there is no report, but also the so-called no conclusions, I do not know him Tuopu Zhengzhou and user enterprises, the two sides should be commercial contract disputes go the judicial process.
High and there is no positive response to a reporter’s "question the quality of Zhengzhou Tuopu mill is true," the question, only said: "They are a reflection of the situation, we have done according to our functions, and understand all of our formal reply, and U.S. reply to prevail. "
However, the Xi’an Heavy Machinery Research Institute of Metallurgical Machinery Lee, director of the Center to the "Daily Economic News" reporter confirmed that by the end of 2007 he participated in the investigation that experts have formed a "testing experts report" and to the AQSIQ. Moreover, the Expert Group and the General Administration of Quality Supervision also signed a protocol, the experts are not authorized to disclose the contents of the report should not, and the judiciary can only be obtained through the General Administration of Quality Supervision report information.
Lee also said that the report involves a matter "very complex", involving a very wide scope, "a lot of enterprises related to the problem now."
AQSIQ did not make public the report, many times, so that users are satisfied with business. Zhejiang Venture thin leaf Ltd. Chairman, said: "We are Zhengzhou Tuopu Health of gas, are now angry with AQSIQ Health."
Ye said that the end of 2007, he caused the production of Zhengzhou Tuopu destructive mill case report to public security organs, public security organs in criminal case, commissioned by Zhejiang Technology Supervision Bureau of the mill equipment testing, testing and survey results will be sent to the quality of Zhejiang Province Inspection Bureau. However, this delay in the provincial food safety test results. Technical Supervision told him the province, the provincial food safety trial did not have time to check test results, saying that Beijing attaches great importance to this matter, people have to call the General Administration of Quality Supervision, Zhejiang respect to the "hello."
Hole and two representatives Wang told reporters: "If there is no true Zhengzhou Tuopu mill quality problems should also be released AQSIQ report to their ‘name’ ah!"
Zhengzhou Tuopu: We were slander and infringement of others
Challenge faced by the parties, Zhengzhou Tuopu company was adamant that the mill did not question the quality.
LIN Zhao, general manager of Zhengzhou Tuopu told "Daily Economic News" reporter, she did not know what "expert report Detected", do not know its contents. Some experts, NPC deputies and lawyers said the contents were defamatory, they have all kinds of Tyrone and the Beijing Association. User enterprises in Beijing are the instigation of Tyrone, slander Tuopu mill has quality problems, so that we can not pay the unpaid part of the money mill.
Zhao said, "Beijing Tyrone" Tyrone is the automation equipment Co., Ltd. Beijing. Zhao March 22 Replies reporter at the cell phone message said: "Beijing is theft Tuopu Tyrone patented technology manufacturing mill tort been sentenced by a court of 29.8 million yuan Tuopu losing party. Yasutaka all of which are engineered by the ’show’ are for them to continue the patent infringement Tuopu. "in 2004, Zhengzhou Tuopu for Hu, Beijing, Zhengzhou, Tyrone company to court in infringement proceedings. Tuopu Hu was Vice General Manager of Zhengzhou, Zhengzhou, left in 2001 after Tuopu Tyrone cooperation with Beijing, Zhengzhou Tuopu use the manufacture and sale of the patented technology mill. July 2006, Zhengzhou Intermediate Court of First Instance handed down: Beijing to set up truth Tyrone infringement, compensation for 29.8 million yuan. This is "the largest patent infringement case."
At present, the patent infringement cases in Beijing are still waiting for the High Court upheld the results.
March 23 morning, a reporter with Zhao near one-hour call, she told reporters in Beijing after a court decision at Tyrone, to the sheet metal business, such as Zhejiang Zhengzhou Tuopu enterprises to ensure that the user can be Tuopu Zhengzhou invalid patent applications I hope that these companies "Let’s say that there is quality problem Tuopu mill." She said that she is already considering a lawsuit against these companies and experts defamation.
Zhao also said that if the mill Tuopu Zhengzhou question really why they are not to the courts? In this regard, should be marked, said Wang, who also studied whether or not to prosecute, but the prosecution of other institutions based on past experience Tuopu Zhengzhou, Zhengzhou Tuopu always win, because "a strong local protectionism."